Gift Guide 2015: Super Sauces

December 1, 2015


Full confession here: I’m addicted to Lady Jayne’s Worcestershire Sauce.  It’s richer, fuller, more exciting than any other Worcestershire sauce I’ve encountered, and even though it’s stunningly expensive ($27 for 3.4 ounces), I’m not surprised it’s sold out. The sheer complexity of this sauce makes absolutely everything taste better; until you’ve had a Caesar salad made with this, you haven’t had Caesar salad.

But it is, I said, sold out; the next batch, currently aging in Bourbon and Rye barrels, will be available sometime next spring. In the meantime, here’s a very decent (but definitely different), substitute.


Col. Pabst Worcestershire Sauce is – no surprise given its pedigree – based primarily on beer. (It’s not Pabst, but a malt amber lager from Lakefront Brewery in Milwaukee).  Unlike the Lady Jayne, which begins with fresh anchovies, the anchovies here are in paste form, and they stay in the background; the major notes, in addition to beer, are apple cider vinegar, Demerara sugar, tomato paste, Tabasco sauce, soy sauce and salt.  There’s a hint of clove in the mix; some ginger and curry too. 

And should you be interested in trying a Lady Jayne product, let me suggest these smelling salts.  One whiff  helps get you through the day. And at $5, a vial 3makes an unusual stocking stuffer.


You can click on the names of the products to go to the various websites, but for those who didn’t realize that, I’m including the links here as well:

Lady Jayne Worcestershire Sauce:

Col Pabst Worcestershire Sauce, $13.95 for 16 ounces from

Smelling salts:

Categorised in:


  • Momma J says:

    A lifetime ago, we made our own Worcestershire sauce, even using smelt, caught in the Columbia River, instead of anchovies!!
    I can’t find the recipe, but it took a week to process, cook, and can in tiny 1/2 pint jars.
    It probably would be pretty costly, making your recommendations look like a deal!!

  • Anonymous says:

    disappointed that both are sold out 🙁